What Do Developers Dislike?
What Do Developers Dislike?
Written by Janet Swift   
Wednesday, 01 November 2017

The Stack Overflow blog has just revealed Perl to be the most disliked programming language, which will be controversial in some circles. But to use a well-worn cliche, there's more to it than that.


stackoverflowbanner

Here's the chart presented by David Robinson, Stack Overflow's Data Scientist, that is making the headlines:

sodislikelang

(click in charts to for enlarged view)

Yes Perl is definitely the clear winner - or rather loser. But notice the scale. It goes from 0% to less than 25% so even though it is an outlier Perl has a dislike score of just 22%, which means that there were more than 4 people who liked it for every person who disliked it.

The thing to understand is that the points are calculated as the number of times a tag is chosen as "disliked" as a proportion of the total  of  "liked" plus "disliked" on the Stack Overflow Jobs site when you create a Developer Story and are not spontaneous expressions of hate.

You have to come up with at least two technologies you want to work with, i.e "like" to set up your profile, and also specify at least two you do not want to work with, i.e" dislike", being restricted to tags that exist on Stack Overflow.

jobprefs

 

For the purposes of the analysis in the chart David Robinson looked at languages that had at least 2,000 mentions on Developer Stories, so to a certain extent languages have to be popular to be on the chart at all as the obscure ones that are disliked won't be mentioned enough.

Another analysis looks at the most disliked technologies - widening the scope to operating systems and platforms as well as languages and reporting the 20 most disliked tags for technologies mentioned at  least 1,000 times. This revealed a much stronger degree of dislike. Internet-Explorer's 82% means that it was disliked by more than three people for every person who liked it. In all eight technologies had a dislike score over 50% - meaning they were disliked more often than liked - and they are predominantly outdated Microsoft technologies, and Flash and Cobol are there too.

sodislikemost

 

When you consider the context of specifying what technologies you want to work and those you prefer to avoid it is obvious that there is going to be a relationship between pairs of choices that form obvious rivals (a bit like theTabs versus Spaces dichotomy that we reported on earlier in the year). This is explored in this chart:

sorivalries

 

This highlights some of the “rivalries” underlying the software ecosystem: Linux and OSX vs Windows, Git vs SVN, vim vs emacs and (unsurprisingly to me) R vs SAS. Most of these pairs don’t represent “opposite” technologies, but instead reflect two approaches to similar problems. Many of them suggest a progression from a formerly popular technology to a more modern one (SVN replaced by Git, XML replaced by JSON, VB replaced by C#). This makes sense in terms of what people would list on a resume; it’s common for developers to specify that they’d rather not work with something they consider outdated.

Something that doesn't make sense to me is why liking backend : disliking frontend has the third strongest relationship,  but that for frontend : backend is vey much weaker. Presumably backend programmers are fleeing questions about what color this comic sans text should be and the frontend programmers just assume backend is the same sort of thing as they are already doing. However it does suggest that it is possibly wrong to use "like" and "dislike" in this context, even though the labels provde a useful shorthand.

Finally you might be interested in this network diagram of polarizing tags. Again Perl appears as an outlier - which it possibly is - but it continues to occupy its singular niche in the developer ecosystem.

 

sopolarized

 

 

More Information

What are the Most Disliked Programming Languages?

 

Banner


AWS Amplify Opens Cloud Services For JavaScript
23/11/2017

Amazon has released an open source library for interacting with cloud services that use JavaScript applications. The AWS Amplify library is organized into a number of categories, with more planne [ ... ]



Cloud Foundry Training and Certification
02/11/2017

A free introductory course on the edX platform, which has just re-opened, can be the initial step on the route to Cloud Foundry certification. And even if you don't want to get certified it will help  [ ... ]


More News

 

 
 

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Last Updated ( Thursday, 09 November 2017 )
 
 

   
Banner
RSS feed of news items only
I Programmer News
Copyright © 2017 i-programmer.info. All Rights Reserved.
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.