Citation map shows top science cities
Citation map shows top science cities
Written by Mike James   
Sunday, 20 March 2011

Which cities around the world produce not just the most but the best scientific papers? Using a database and Google Maps the answer is obvious.

One of the exciting things about the web is the way that it brings data from different sources together - a little clever processing and you can reveal something that was previously difficult to see. 

A paper in Physics arXiv describes how two researchers combined citation data with Google maps to create a plot showing how important cities around the world were in terms of their contribution to  physics, chemistry or psychology.

The idea is simple enough - scientific papers cite other scientific papers and it is usually held that the more a paper is cited the more important it is. So taking the data from the Web-of-Science database the researchers simply counted how many papers originated from each city and plotted a circle with a radius proportional to the number of papers on Google Maps.

They then looked at the number of papers that you would expect to be in the top 10% most cited papers from each city, i.e. 10% of the papers compared to the number that were actually in the top 10%. The difference indicates how successful the city is in producing important papers and not just their volume. They plotted the circles in red for lower performing cities and green for higher performing cities.

So a small green circle indicates a small high quality output and a big red circle indicates a high volume but lower quality output.




Inspecting the maps raises questions on several levels such as how language affects citations and the effects of isolated communities of researchers who cite each other's work but do not make references outside of their circle. Even so it is an interesting study.

You can read the complete paper at.







Word Of The Year Is An Emoji

The Face with Tears of Joy emoji has become Oxford Dictionaries 2015 Word of the Year, raising the question of can an emoji be considered to have the status of a word.

Computer Pioneer Gene Amdahl Dies

Gene Amdahl, the computer architect who designed the IBM System/360 and the first LSI-based mainframe, has died at the age of 92.

More News

Last Updated ( Sunday, 20 March 2011 )

RSS feed of news items only
I Programmer News
Copyright © 2015 All Rights Reserved.
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.